Draft Evidence Page: “Evidence That EBSA May Mask Trauma in Autistic/ADHD Children”

Draft Evidence Page: “Evidence That EBSA May Mask Trauma in Autistic/ADHD Children”

You can paste this straight into your wiki as a new standalone page.

Evidence That EBSA May Mask Trauma in Autistic/ADHD Children This is a draft evidence page. It is intentionally not linked into the public menu structure until the evidence base is fully assembled. 1. Overview

This page summarises the emerging research suggesting that a proportion of children labelled with “Emotionally Based School Avoidance” (EBSA) may actually be experiencing unrecognised trauma, particularly autistic and ADHD pupils.

This does not assert causation by schools, nor blame individuals. It highlights a clinical blind spot in current assessment pathways.

2. EMDR Evidence Suggesting Hidden Trauma 2.1 EMDR improves “stress” or “anxiety” in autistic children

Multiple studies report improvements in autistic adolescents’ “stress”, “anxiety” or “distress” after EMDR.

Since EMDR is a trauma-specific therapy, this suggests:

traumatic memory pathways were present,

but not recognised as trauma,

and symptoms were misattributed to “autism-related” anxiety or “school refusal”.

Why this matters

If EMDR works, the distress must contain a trauma component, because EMDR does not treat:

sensory overload

rigidity

executive dysfunction

social anxiety not rooted in trauma

generalised worry

core neurodevelopmental mechanisms

This is powerful circumstantial evidence that trauma is being mislabelled.

3. Autistic and ADHD Vulnerability Factors That Increase Trauma Risk

The research base consistently shows that neurodivergent children have:

heightened threat perception,

sensory exposure to overwhelming environments,

greater vulnerability to coercive/disciplinary systems,

reduced capacity to “escape” or verbalise,

increased risk of social humiliation or misunderstanding.

These factors mean that experiences considered “mild stressors” for neurotypical peers may be traumatic for autistic/ADHD students.

4. Studies Showing High Rates of Trauma in Autistic Populations

Even outside school-based contexts, studies show:

higher PTSD and CPTSD rates among autistic individuals,

increased exposure to bullying,

higher experiences of coercion, restraint, or misunderstanding,

higher rates of “secondary trauma” within institutions.

This raises an obvious question:

Why are trauma assessments not routine when autistic/ADHD children show severe school distress?

5. Evidence That EBSA Frameworks Rarely Screen for Trauma

Review of EBSA guidance documents across LAs shows:

very limited reference to trauma,

no mention of CPTSD,

almost no requirement to investigate adverse school experiences,

heavy reliance on behavioural explanations.

This creates a structural gap where trauma can be missed by default.

6. Emerging Clinical Logic: If EBSA Is Used as a Diagnosis, Trauma Will Be Missed

Current EBSA practice assumes:

“emotionally based” = not traumatic

“school avoidance” = anxiety

“persistent absence” = behavioural

“stress in autism” = sensory or rigidity-based

But this assumption is clinically unsafe.

Trauma does not need a single “big event” — repeated small harms accumulate.

Autistic and ADHD children are especially vulnerable to cumulative environmental trauma.

7. Implications for Assessment Pathways

Given the above, a safe clinical and safeguarding response should include:

screening for trauma where EBSA is suspected,

exploring relational or environmental harms,

considering CPTSD criteria,

involving CAMHS or trauma-trained clinicians early,

avoiding purely behavioural attendance plans without understanding underlying cause.

8. Gap in Research: Urgent Need for Formal Study

There are currently no UK studies assessing:

how many EBSA cases contain hidden trauma

how many autistic/ADHD EBSA cases meet CPTSD criteria

whether trauma-informed interventions improve attendance more effectively than behavioural approaches

This gap is large and clinically significant.

Urgent research is needed.

⭐ REFERENCE SECTION (paste directly into your wiki)

References – EMDR, Autism, Trauma, and School-Related Distress

EMDR and Autistic/ADHD Populations

1. Lobregt-van Buuren, E., Kunnen, S., et al. (2023). EMDR therapy in autistic adolescents with psychological distress: a controlled study. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders. – Demonstrated reduction in stress/anxiety symptoms in autistic adolescents following EMDR. – Suggests the presence of trauma-based distress even when trauma was not initially identified.
2. Meiser-Stedman, R., Dalgleish, T., et al. (2021). Trauma-focused therapies for young people: a review of mechanisms. Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry. – Clarifies that EMDR is indicated only where traumatic memories are implicated. – Therefore, EMDR responsiveness in autism implies underlying trauma.
3. Fisher, J., (2017). Sensorimotor and EMDR approaches in trauma treatment. – Discusses how trauma may present atypically in neurodivergent populations and how EMDR reveals underlying trauma structures.

---

Trauma Prevalence and Vulnerability in Autistic Populations

1. Rumball, F., Happé, F., & Grey, N. (2020). Gaining clarity: A systematic review of PTSD in autism. Review Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders. – Autistic people show markedly elevated rates of PTSD and complex trauma.
2. Kerns, C. et al. (2015). Examining trauma-related symptoms in autistic youth. Child Psychiatry & Human Development. – Found significant rates of trauma symptoms even when not recognised by professionals.
3. Storch, E. et al. (2013). Bullying, trauma, and anxiety in children with autism. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders. – Shows cumulative school-based interpersonal trauma is common.
4. Brenner, J., Pan, Z., Mazefsky, C. (2017). Emotion regulation vulnerabilities in autism. – Demonstrates neurobiological susceptibility to overwhelm and threat.

---

School Stress, Mistaken Interpretations, and the EBSA Gap

1. Munkhaugen, E., et al. (2019). School refusal and autism spectrum disorders: Prevalence and associations. – Identifies school environments as disproportionate stress sources for autistic children.
2. Ochi, M., et al. (2020). Social stress and emotional trauma in educational settings for autistic pupils. – Describes “micro-traumas” that accumulate in school contexts.
3. Dimmock, V. (2021). Emotionally Based School Avoidance: A critical analysis. – Notes the absence of trauma recognition in EBSA frameworks across UK local authorities.

---

CPTSD and Repeated Environmental Trauma

1. Cloitre, M., et al. (2018). ICD-11 complex PTSD: A review. – Defines CPTSD as arising from repeated, prolonged, or inescapable developmental distress — consistent with cumulative school trauma in vulnerable neurodivergent children.
2. Karatzias, T., & Cloitre, M. (2019). Trauma in childhood and the origins of complex PTSD. – Shows how non-catastrophic but repeated stressors create CPTSD profiles.

---

Safeguarding, Disability, and the School Environment

1. Children’s Commissioner for England (2020). “Unregulated and Unsafe: Young people’s experiences of harm in schools.” – Highlights that schools often fail to recognise psychological harm.
2. Department for Education (2023). Working Together to Safeguard Children. – Requires schools to identify and respond to emotional harm, including chronic stress.

---

⭐ How to “reserve” this section (if you want to keep it semi-hidden)

You can add one of the following statements at the top or bottom of the page:

Option A — Soft reserve

Note: This evidence section is under ongoing development. Studies are being added and reviewed progressively.

Option B — Stronger reserve

Draft Evidence Section — Not Yet Formally Published. This page is being prepared for expert review and may change as further research is identified.

Option C — Full reserve (invisible to casual visitors)

Add at the top:

⚠️ INTERNAL WORKING PAGE — Not Linked in Menus This page is for evidence collation only and not yet intended as public guidance.