When Phonics Is Proving a Problem

This page is part of the School Issues section.

• Return to main navigation:* School_Issues

When Phonics Is Proving a Problem

Reading should open doors — not close them. For most children, learning to read is exciting and empowering. But for some, particularly autistic or neurodivergent learners, synthetic phonics — the UK method of breaking words into sounds and blending them — can become confusing, distressing, and damaging to confidence.

This guide is for parents who feel something isn’t right but don’t know what to do next. It explains what’s happening, why it’s happening, and how to get help lawfully and calmly.

🔍 What Synthetic Phonics Is

Synthetic phonics teaches children to:

Hear individual sounds in words (phonemes)

Blend those sounds together to read

Segment words back into sounds to spell

It’s the structured system used in most UK schools — and it works well for many children. But not for everyone.

Children with autism, ADHD, dyslexia, auditory-processing disorder, or working-memory differences may understand language perfectly yet find phonics illogical or overwhelming. They may appear to learn short words (like cat or dog) but then get “stuck” as words grow longer or rules become inconsistent.

This guide refers specifically to synthetic phonics (breaking and blending sounds), not to basic phonics knowledge (learning the sounds of letters). Understanding letter-sound relationships is helpful; the issue arises when a rigid, synthetic process is imposed on children whose processing profile makes it distressing or ineffective.

⚠️ When Phonics Becomes a Barrier

You may notice:

Your child understands spoken language but struggles to decode new words

Meltdowns, tears, or anxiety around reading homework

“I hate reading” or “I’m stupid”

School avoidance or tummy aches on literacy days

A sudden stop in progress after early phonics stages

Better understanding when listening than when reading

These are not signs of laziness. They are signs of processing overload — the phonics method demands too many steps of working memory, attention, and sound manipulation at once. When this happens, continuing without adapting the method can harm your child’s confidence and block access to reading.

✅ What You Can Do

If you suspect phonics is the problem:

Notice patterns: Keep notes of when distress or confusion happens.

Talk to the teacher: Ask how your child responds in class and whether progress is genuine or just repeated practice.

Request reasonable adjustments: You have the right under the Equality Act 2010 to ask for alternative teaching that removes distress or disadvantage.

Protect your child’s confidence: Use real books, audiobooks, and shared or immersive reading at home — focus on meaning, not decoding.

Document everything: Keep copies of emails, homework, and notes of conversations.

📚 Law and Rights (Simple Version)

The Equality Act 2010 says schools must:

Change teaching methods that disadvantage disabled children

Prevent emotional harm and harassment

Act early — not wait for a diagnosis

Make reasonable adjustments to remove barriers

That means schools can and must change phonics teaching if it causes distress or prevents learning. This includes adapting or skipping the Year 1 Phonics Screening Check.

🧭 Where to Go Next

This wiki gives you practical guidance, letters, and support at every step:

Recognising Distress and Harm

Alternative Reading Approaches

Working with Schools

Legal Rights and Letters

Evidence and Research

Protecting Wellbeing

Next Steps and Tribunal Options

💬 You are not fighting the school — you’re standing up for your child’s right to learn safely and meaningfully.

---

Disclaimer: This page is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. For individual guidance, contact SENDIASS, IPSEA, or the Equality Advisory and Support Service (EASS). See the full Legal and Support Disclaimer for details.